Page 2 of 4
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Sun Feb 23, 2025 2:52 pm
by park44
@olga_lind Follow-up question though -
Regenerative braking on humanoid joints can recover some energy during deceleration phases of walking, but the actual energy recovered is modest compared to a vehicle, since humanoid joints don't sustain the same continuous high-speed rotation that makes regen worthwhile in EVs. Hot-swappable battery packs solve the runtime bottleneck for continuous operations (like a 24/7 warehouse shift) without needing a much bigger, heavier pack, but they add mechanical complexity, a failure-prone connector interface, and logistics overhead for managing spare packs.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Sun Feb 23, 2025 10:25 pm
by williams84
@park44 This matches what I've seen too.
DC-DC conversion losses across all the individual actuator drivers add up across a whole robot - it's a less glamorous efficiency question than battery chemistry, but power electronics efficiency meaningfully affects real-world runtime too.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Sun Feb 23, 2025 11:59 pm
by jonathan.rao1
@williams84 Thanks for laying this out, genuinely useful.
Idle/standing power draw is often surprisingly close to a meaningful fraction of active walking power draw once you account for onboard compute, sensors, and balance-holding torque - 'doing nothing' still costs real energy on a humanoid. Regenerative braking on humanoid joints can recover some energy during deceleration phases of walking, but the actual energy recovered is modest compared to a vehicle, since humanoid joints don't sustain the same continuous high-speed rotation that makes regen worthwhile in EVs.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Thu Mar 06, 2025 5:08 am
by sarah.santos3
@jonathan.rao1 Thanks for laying this out, genuinely useful.
A BMS (battery management system) has to guard against transient current spikes from sudden gait changes or lifting motions, not just steady-state draw - peak current headroom and fast-acting protection logic matter as much as total capacity for real-world duty cycles.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2025 10:31 pm
by park44
@sarah.santos3 Slightly off-topic, but related:
Solid-state battery claims from platforms like XPeng's IRON, GAC's GoMate, and EngineAI's T800 are genuinely promising on paper for energy density and safety margins, but independent, large-scale field validation of those runtime claims is still fairly limited as of 2026 - it's real progress, not yet fully proven at scale. There's no widely standardized safety certification specific to humanoid battery packs yet in most jurisdictions - deployments generally lean on adapted versions of existing standards for industrial battery systems and electrical safety rather than a purpose-built humanoid standard.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Thu Mar 13, 2025 5:24 pm
by williams84
@park44 Ran into exactly this myself.
Idle/standing power draw is often surprisingly close to a meaningful fraction of active walking power draw once you account for onboard compute, sensors, and balance-holding torque - 'doing nothing' still costs real energy on a humanoid. Fast charging accelerates capacity fade over repeated cycles, so fleet operators generally have to choose between minimizing downtime (fast charging) and maximizing pack lifespan (slower charging or swap-based approaches) rather than getting both for free.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2025 6:02 am
by noah_pate
Related question -
Hot-swappable battery packs solve the runtime bottleneck for continuous operations (like a 24/7 warehouse shift) without needing a much bigger, heavier pack, but they add mechanical complexity, a failure-prone connector interface, and logistics overhead for managing spare packs.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:13 am
by sarah.santos3
@noah_pate Agreed, and I'd add:
Best-in-class lithium-ion cells used in humanoids are currently landing around 280-300 Wh/kg, which is respectable but still leaves battery mass as one of the largest single contributors to total robot weight. Hot-swappable battery packs solve the runtime bottleneck for continuous operations (like a 24/7 warehouse shift) without needing a much bigger, heavier pack, but they add mechanical complexity, a failure-prone connector interface, and logistics overhead for managing spare packs.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2025 1:57 am
by barbara.jones
@sarah.santos3 Counterpoint:
DC-DC conversion losses across all the individual actuator drivers add up across a whole robot - it's a less glamorous efficiency question than battery chemistry, but power electronics efficiency meaningfully affects real-world runtime too.
Reminds me a bit of the early drone hobbyist scene, honestly.
Re: What's the biggest power system failure you've personally diagnosed?
Posted: Wed Apr 16, 2025 7:39 am
by ramirez77
Sorry if this is a basic question, but
Idle/standing power draw is often surprisingly close to a meaningful fraction of active walking power draw once you account for onboard compute, sensors, and balance-holding torque - 'doing nothing' still costs real energy on a humanoid.